Publisher’s note: The Vermont state legislature’s passage of Act 46 into law has prompted school districts across the Green Mountains to look more closely at consolidation. Here’s some “big picture” thinking from Diane Ravitch on the true nature of the “crisis” in our imperial public schools.

‘The crisis in education today,’ writes Ravitch, ‘is an existential threat to the survival of public education.’ (Image: Photo by Dean Hochman/flickr/cc w/ overlay)

 It has become conventional wisdom that “education is in crisis.” I have been asked about this question by many interviewers. They say something like: “Do you think American education is in crisis? What is the cause of the crisis?” And I answer, “Yes, there is a crisis, but it is not the one you have read about. The crisis in education today is an existential threat to the survival of public education. The threat comes from those who unfairly blame the school for social conditions, and then create a false narrative of failure. The real threat is privatization and the loss of a fundamental democratic institution.”

As we have seen again and again, the corporate education industry is eager to break into U.S. public education and turn it into a free marketplace, where they can monetize the schools and be assured of government subsidization. On the whole, these privatized institutions do not produce higher test scores than regular public schools, except for those that cherry-pick their students and exclude the neediest and lowest performing students. The promotion of privatization by philanthropies, by the U.S. Department of Education, by right-wing governors (and a few Democratic governors like Cuomo of New York and Malloy of Connecticut), by the hedge fund industry, and by a burgeoning education equities industry poses a danger to our democracy. In some communities, public schools verge on bankruptcy as charters drain their resources and their best students. Nationwide, charter schools have paved the way for vouchers by making “school choice” non-controversial.

Yes, education is in crisis. The profession of teaching is threatened by the financial powerhouse Teach for America, which sells the bizarre idea that amateurs are more successful than experienced teachers. TFA — and the belief in amateurism — has also facilitated the passage of legislation to strip teachers of basic rights to due process and of salaries tied to experience and credentials.

Education is in crisis because of the explosion of testing and the embrace by government of test scores as both the means and the end of education. The scores are treated as a measure of teacher effectiveness and school effectiveness, when they are in fact a measure of the family income of the students enrolled in the school. The worst consequence of the romance with standardized testing is that children are ranked, sorted, and assigned a value based on scores that are not necessarily scientific or objective. Children thus become instruments, tools, objects, rather than unique human beings, each with his or her own potential.

Education is in crisis because of the calculated effort to turn it into a business with a bottom line. Schools are closed and opened as though they were chain stores, not community institutions. Teachers are fired based on flawed measures. Disruption is considered a strategy rather than misguided and inhumane policy. Children and educators alike are simply data points, to be manipulated by economists, statisticians, entrepreneurs, and dabblers in policy.

Education has lost its way, lost its purpose, lost its definition. Where once it was about enlightening and empowering young minds with knowledge, exploring new worlds, learning about science and history, and unleashing the imagination of each child, it has become a scripted process of producing test scores that can supply data.

Education is in crisis. And we must organize to resist, to push back, to fight the mechanization of learning, and the standardization of children.

Diane Ravitch is a historian of education at New York University. Her most recent book is Reign of Error: The Hoax of the Privatization Movement and the Danger to America’s Public Schools.  Her previous books and articles about American education include: The Death and Life of the Great American School System: How Testing and Choice Are Undermining Education, Left Back: A Century of Battles Over School Reform, (Simon & Schuster, 2000); The Language Police: How Pressure Groups Restrict What Students Learn (Knopf, 2003); The English Reader: What Every Literate Person Needs to Know(Oxford, 2006), which she edited with her son Michael Ravitch. She lives in Brooklyn, New York.

April 2, 2016

What Education Crisis? Act 46, Consolidation and Vermont’s Public Schools

Publisher’s note: The Vermont state legislature’s passage of Act 46 into law has prompted school districts across the Green Mountains to look more closely at consolidation. […]
April 2, 2016

Breaking News! Vermont Secedes from the U.S. Empire

In surprise move, Vermont quietly and peacefully seceded from the U.S. of Empire overnight, declaring Bernie Sanders our newly-elected interim president until a qualified WOMAN is […]
April 1, 2016

Sweet! Vermont Maple Fest 2016

Happening this week-end in sugar houses all over the Green Mountains. Come get some of the good stuff. Click here for a complete schedule.
March 28, 2016

Psyching Out Climate Change: “Grounding Hope” for Vermont’s Future

Almost all of what we hear in the news today, in relation to the environment, tends to be on the topic of the anthropogenic degradation of […]
March 28, 2016

Cannabis Regulation for Vermont: TEN Good Reasons

2VR has been working on Vermont cannabis regulation for more than a year, in conversation with a wide variety of Vermont stake holding groups. Summarizing one […]
March 28, 2016

Kickstarting “Wetware” – Vermont Filmmakers Peer into the Future.

Read more about Kingdom County Productions Jay Craven’s collaborative production of “Wetware” here.
March 24, 2016

Greening Vermont, Building a More Resilient Future

Here in Vermont, as everywhere, the built environment has a vast impact on the natural environment, human health, and the economy. 40% of our energy consumption […]
March 21, 2016

Vermont Town Meeting: Why It Matters More Than Ever

Alert viewers of WCAX may have noticed a March 4 segment calling attention to my completion of 50 years’ service as Kirby town moderator. Please allow […]
March 20, 2016

Vermont Kicks the GMO Food Industry’s Ass – You Are Welcome, Cereal Eaters Everywhere.

  Publisher’s note: We love a good Vermont’centric David and Goliath story. MONTPELIER, Vt. (AP) — General Mills’ announcement on Friday that it will start labeling […]
March 19, 2016

Are Vermonters Suffering From Our “Normalcy Bias”?

A friend of mine says a lot of Vermonters are about to get a rude awakening over the next couple of weeks as the traditional sugaring […]
March 18, 2016

Deadpool: Super Hero/Split Personality on the Silver Screen

Debut director Tim Miller’s new superhero flick “Deadpool” is a case study in super hero split personality. Critics and audiences love this film, but truthfully, I’m […]
March 18, 2016

Tree Base’ing: Vermont’s Logging Industry – Past, Present and Future

Publisher’s Note: As 21st century fossil fuel energy resources dwindle in the Age of Peak Oil, Vermont will become more reliant once again on its forests, […]